Access whitepaper

Where Forrester Misses HUGE on Corporate Blogging

Tuesday, December 9, 2008 by Douglas Karr
The big hubbub on the web today on the web is Josh Bernoff's research paper from Forrester, People Don't Trust Corporate Blogs!  That title is what we in the Internet business call 'link bait', a captivating title that really doesn't mean what it says.

The big audacious bullet point of Josh's research is that only 16% of people trust corporate blogs, less than other mediums.  Josh leaves the meat of the analysis out of his blog post and in the download - a real disappointment.  To give him credit, Josh does tell people that they really need to download the full analysis and give it thought.

The walk away from the analysis is this:
  • People don't trust companies.
  • Since they do not trust companies, they're definitely not going to trust some new technology that a company adopts that might be used to try to manipulate them.
  • The majority of corporate blogs suck.
Compendium Blogware agrees with most of Forrester's research, although we don't appreciate the disinformation that might be spread by the link bait.  Josh knows that most readers remember snippets - like titles - and don't take the time to read the full analysis.
  • Compendium believes that the majority of corporate blogs are not necessarily untrustworthy, but most do suck.
  • We're tired of all the experts providing terrible corporate blogging advice that is prevalent on the web right now.  These voices have clogged the Internet and left unrealistic expectations of companies on how blogging will help them and how they should leverage blogging to drive sales and build relationships with their customers.
  • Corporate blogging should be leveraged to build online search authority, ranking, and acquisition - not simply a tool for building trust.
  • Corporate blogs should provide relevant content that answers the questions that the reader is looking for.  That means speaking to the customer, about the customer, and how you can help that reader.
If you really want to get to the good stuff, download Josh's full analysis, which provides some good advice on When and How to Blog for Business.  His key point is something that Chris Baggott tells people in every presentation:
Like any other marketing channel, blogging can work. But it’s not about you; it’s about your customer. Our rule of thumb is that if the person reading the blog says, “Sure I don’t trust corporate blogs, but I don’t think of your blog that way,” then you’re on the right track.
Where Forrester totally missed the mark:

Josh provides some feedback on when and how a business should blog but he totally left out Search Engine Marketing, an absolute disappointment.  In other words, Forrester has perpetuated the myth of corporate blogging as only a tool to build relationships and fuzzy little Web 2.0 terms like engagement.

Corporate blogging is becoming a key strategy in conversions and acquisition in a search engine strategy.  I can't believe that Forrester left out the search component associated with the benefits of corporate blogging! 

Most consumers start their activity on the web from a web search... that means that your company's placement in those results should be key to your online marketing strategy.
Spread the Word

Comments for Where Forrester Misses HUGE on Corporate Blogging

Tuesday, December 9, 2008 by Michael E. Rubin, Blog Council:
Doug, "Compendium believes that the majority of corporate blogs are not necessarily untrustworthy, but most do suck." Really? Come on, you know better than that. I think that corporate blogs have come a LONG way in a very short amount of time. This isn't 2003 when Robert Scoble was the only corporate blogger around. Obviously I'm biased, but the ones we link to on the Blog Council blog are definitely trustworthy and most definitely do not suck. They do what corporate bloggers do best: talk with an authentic voice, help real people solve real problems. http://blogcouncil.org/blog/here-are-a-few-trustworthy-corporate-blogs/ Cheers, Michael ---- 312-932-9000 / michael@blogcouncil.org / twitter: merubin I am a Blog Council employee and this is my personal opinion.
Wednesday, December 10, 2008 by Douglas Karr:
We are getting better, Michael. And you've put out some good blogs, I agree. You can't ignore the fact that 75% of corporate blogs fail (I believe another Forrester stat) is evidence that 'most do suck'. Both our organizations are dedicated to reversing those numbers, but misinformation like this Forrester post is not helping!
Wednesday, December 10, 2008 by Erik Deckers:
Forrester? Aren't these the same guys who said more people will be driven to do email marketing because there will be 840 billion email messages by 2013? I tend to take a lot of things Forrester says with a grain of salt, because it seems to be a lot of corporate hyperbole. Sure, they've got their research methods, but I sometimes wonder if they believe what they're saying, or if they're more like the WWE of research organizations.
Thursday, December 11, 2008 by Michael E. Rubin, Blog Council:
Aye, that we can agree on, Doug. You guys do terrific work, no doubt about it. And yes, the headline is not helping. That's why it's important to point out positive examples of blogs that do work and do not suck. For example, look at one of the example Josh wrote about in the report: Rubbermaid. (*) You have Jim Deitzel blogging about getting organized, preparing for the holidays, getting ready for New Year's, etc. It's fun and personal. He even posted pictures of his kids. Yes, he talks about Rubbermaid products, but in the context of getting organized and helping to solve real world customer problems. How any of that could generate mistrust is beyond me. cheers, Michael ---- 312-932-9000 / michael@blogcouncil.org / twitter: merubin I am a Blog Council employee and this is my personal opinion. * Rubbermaid is a Blog Council member. I write about them because I like them and they are good people.

Leave a comment





Captcha

© 2009 Compendium Blogware
All Rights Reserved